El Clasico open thread: Copa del Rey 1/18/12
I know most of us here will be watching, so I figured an open thread might be fun. Expect all sorts of diving, eye pokes, controversy, and complaining to the referees. There might actually be some brilliant soccer in there as well. Anyway, here are your starting lineups:
Real Madrid: Casillas, Altintop, Carvalho, Ramos, Coentrao, Diarra, Alonso, Pepe, Ronaldo, Higuain, Benzema
Subs: Adan, Albiol, Marcelo, Granero, Kaka, Ozil, Callejon
FC Barcelona: Pinto, Alves, Pique, Puyol, Abidal, Busquets, Xavi, Iniesta, Messi, Fabregas, Sanchez
Subs: Valdes, Corriea, Mascherano, Dos Santos, Alcantara, Roberto, Cuenca
I'm still debating whether to switch off this stimulating Wolves/Birmingham FA Cup draw, but to each his own I guess. Have at it...
205 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Ozil?
No creative midfielder? I like the Ronaldo Benzema Higuain trio at the top but I feel like they’re going to miss Ozil…
by lbcgalactico on Jan 18, 2012 8:36 PM GMT via Android app reply actions
Mourinho's game plan is usually in stages
First defend to halftime, keep it 0-0. Then attack.
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 9:00 PM GMT up reply actions
It should be interesting at least
I guess I’ll pry myself away from the Wolves game
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 8:45 PM GMT up reply actions
Sad but, pretty, true
once upon a recent time we would have had a few players either of these clubs would gladly have nicked but tonight I struggle to think of a single outfield player who would get in either side and, sadder, even on the bench. Possibly we could squeeze SOMETHING in in Altintytop’s stead but who? They may be two morally defunct turd hole clubs but their better TV income(which cripples their league and suits only them and is unfair on EVERY club in the CL)allied to their dubiously claimed history ensures we will NEVER be able to compete when the FFP rules come in and it’s amazing just how far we have fallen behind since 5 or six years ago.
Cech might, even on current form beat out Barca’s keepers but Ash is too tired because he never gets a rest and is getting too old to play every second so is no longer close to his World class best and wouldn’t come close to these sides currently. JT isn’t coping as well, bodily, he used to and, though it pains me, isn’t close to Riccy even though he’s younger and he’s abut the weakest CB on display while Luiz might one day(along with DS, Mata and Rambo) get there he hasn’t got there yet.
Saddest of all Romeu might get there too but should he manage it why on Earth stay with us? Straight back home, sadly, sao training him up is just wasting our time. I guess if Torres gets back to form he’s capable matching any of the strikers but riht now, again, not even close while Lamps and Dd, generally, aren’t coming back to their full prowess-Lamps these days can only score the share of the goals heb used to if he fails in other respects where he used to chip in like creating and defending. Maaking his trademark runs is what he’s stupidly concentrating on and its sidelimning him and killing his chances of being part of plan A long term. He continues not to alter his game to fit in he will make his goals only desirable as a special occasional starting effort and mostly be a bench impact player. as someone the media portrays as clever he’s being a bit stubborn and daft in thinking a watered down Lamps of old is what we need and selfishly feels that the goals are enough to keep him relevant and they aren’t while they now mean he’s always out of position as he can’t cover back or make them from as deep as he used to. He’s nt being fair to himself, his ability(he COULD create more if he’d try to change because he USED to create a lot more than he now does and I think it’s because he’s more arsed about his opwn goals and trying desperately to keep a team servicing HIM and it won’t happen and shouldn’t when it means he offers less than he once did)or to us or tyhe team and is giving away any chance he has of being our Giggs and getting back to being good enough for a place fo Real or Barca.
Honestly, if we don’t start buying a FEW players and also get a few kids into the team now and then to find out if they can make the grade we wil forever fall so far behind we can never make the gap up again. no sin of a big enough ground and little chance, in my eyes, of beating Napoli, winning the FA and only a 50/50 given our form and squad of finishing in the top four. It’s bad enough how weak we are compared to these giants(should we play Barca now Cole wouldn’t be our saviour as he used to be and we couldn’t “do a Valencia at home” as they’d murder us)but when you think how Spurs have managed more from lower transfer fees, lower wages, a terribly ignorant manager, smaller ground and worse youth set up than us you have to worry, don’t you? If Harry had a clue tactically Spurs, shuddrs, would be top right now so where have we managed to go THIS wrong?
I’m not blaming any one man or manager and feel the power given to mere players(because they won us our first ever real period of success I get why it happened)has ruined us and we will have to build a cxlub ethos from scratch without nearly all of them to succeed ever again. If we were to repeat the error of allowing Terry and Lamps, DD and Cech the power they have had with future plasyers it will be terminal in terms of us even being relevant in the EPL. Bigger capacity, better discipline, lower wages but better players and a way of stopping the academy being nothing more than a money pit(currently losing us loads, millions a season on top of the forty million already put into the grounds and scouting)and atctually gettiung a manager to have enough faith to play (Bertrand after seven loans should be playing to allow Ash a rest or be allowed to go and get us money back in for example)youngsters rather than, in Josh’s case, a risky loan that through none of his fault will likely be a farce. Needed more here but if we won’t trust him why sould they? Their midfield works for them and even a great kid will be up and down so Josh won’t be their saviour if he DOES play and, imho, he’s unlikely to fit better than their own and was more likely to improve on Meireles here. Daft and dafter in my eyes.
by mastiffchild on Jan 18, 2012 10:18 PM GMT up reply actions
Long response is long
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
tl; dr
More Chelsea hate. Still no happiness for ‘mastiffchild’, but I suppose that is the English way.
It has paragraphs and punctuation.
You can do it!
El Classico V.2
These things are always hilarious to watch. I’m curious to see how Altintop plays…
Seems a strange formation from Mourinho on paper
Should be stout through the middle when Barca has the ball, but Ronaldo is the only actual creative player on the pitch for them.
Bullpen Banter
Fan: Seattle Mariners, Seattle Sounders FC, Liverpool
Twitter
by c_dowley on Jan 18, 2012 8:48 PM GMT via Android app reply actions
I really dislike both of these teams.
I get why people watch it for the hugeness of the occasion and the quality on show, but watching these two diving, whiny teams have hissy fits and argue really never appealled to me.
oh
Mou is going with a defensive 4-3-3? Pepe alonso and diarra in d mid..seems like a plan..
by winningisourgame on Jan 18, 2012 8:50 PM GMT via mobile reply actions
oh yes
thats a nice plan :D
by winningisourgame on Jan 18, 2012 8:53 PM GMT via mobile up reply actions
Any guesses are on number of cards?
I’ll say there are 7 yellows, no reds.
by Joe DelGreco on Jan 18, 2012 8:54 PM GMT up reply actions
barca
4 reds. Rmadrid get 3 points. Im happy
by winningisourgame on Jan 18, 2012 8:56 PM GMT via mobile up reply actions
inverted triangle is my guess
Alonso passing from deep and positioned on top of the defense while Diarra and Pepe destroy barca’s deep playmakers before they can begin to string attacks
I'm gonna say something unpopular
I think Ronaldo is the better pure player, but Messi is the better player within his system. Messi plays off of the other Barca guys better than Ronaldo “plays” (doesn’t) off of the RM guys, and also the Barca guys on average are better than the RM guys. So Messi ends up being the best player in the world, hands down. But in isolation, Ronaldo might be the better pure player. Like if you took them both and stuck them on a random non-league side, which would shine more?
Ronaldo doesn't, didn't, and won't have Barcelona's system behind him.
If Ronaldo had Iniesta and Xavi he’d be an even better player statistically than the 50 goal monster he was last season.
Ronaldo will spoil Iniesta and Xavi
Just like he did with Ozil. He is not a team player
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:11 PM GMT up reply actions
There's a world of difference between Ozil
and the arguable two best midfielders in the world. He doesn’t need to reciprocate with them, he just needs them to feed him the ball, which they’re terrific at. More touches in better places would lead to more goals.
CR7 might improve with them
But Xavi and Inesta are better with Messi, who is more of a team player.
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:16 PM GMT up reply actions
Oh, agreed completely.
But Ronaldo and Messi put in almost identical seasons last year, with Ronaldo setting a La Liga goals scored record. And Messi definitely had the better team support.
So were they to swap teams, I think CR7’s numbers would increase, and Messi’s decrease. But I’d far prefer Messi as a player on my team.
CR7 is more of a goalscorer
While Messi likes to get involved in the buildup and is a better overall payer.
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:25 PM GMT up reply actions
Messi's a worse overall player
Ronaldo is a significantly better defender
by Graham MacAree on Jan 18, 2012 10:56 PM GMT up reply actions
mine is working.
took me a while though. also, spanish commentators! gooooooooooooooooooooool!!!!!!
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 9:01 PM GMT up reply actions
Like an inner-city youth resorting to a life of crime
I’ve been forced to turn to the wonders of Veetle+iPhone. This is on you, ESPN3.
But at least I can even do work at the same time this way!
Also, I still love you, Riccy Carvalho.
Terrible goalkeeping there
Nice to see Barca losing :)
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:15 PM GMT reply actions
That was some world class crying
Romeu has much to learn if he wants to return and displace Biscuits
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:22 PM GMT up reply actions
Poor guy
You couldn’t pay me enough to have to deal with this crap
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:25 PM GMT up reply actions
I'd pay to officiate it.
I’d card for diving, and then for arguing. It’d be glorious.
Barca is lucky they've only given up 1
Real looks like they could absolutely destroy them on the counter today
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:28 PM GMT reply actions
He's been everywhere today
Great performance thus far. I guess he wants to make up for those sitters
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:30 PM GMT up reply actions
This linesman is terrible
That’s the 4th clear offsides he’s missed that led to a Barca chance
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:37 PM GMT reply actions
Real need to check their cleats at the half
Slipping everywhere
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:47 PM GMT reply actions
I've been far more impressed this year by Real than Barca
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 9:52 PM GMT up reply actions
I'm still bitter that they have Sahin and don't even play him.
He’s on my Chelsea ultimate wish list.
Sahin to Chelsea for 10 mil
Would have been the best signing .
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 9:57 PM GMT up reply actions 1 recs
Alexis looks like the main man for Barca today
By Next Year he would be better then Ronaldo (For me he already is better then CR7)
He's already surpassed his skill in the diving department
That’s been a relatively disappointing development since he arrived at Barca
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 10:03 PM GMT up reply actions
You dint surpass Ronaldo in the diving department
He has the special art of looking at the ref and appealing in mid air.
CR7 practices diving more then he practices dribbling and way more then passing

by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:09 PM GMT up reply actions
Wow
You went too far mate. Ronaldinho was by far the best player to appear in Barça. Messi is hors concours.
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
I was talking about Critiano Ronaldo
As for Ronaldinho I have seen very little of him
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:12 PM GMT up reply actions
Real Madrid well deserved lead going into the second half
And more impressively, they’ve really done well to shut down the Barcelona trio of Xavi, Iniesta, and Messi. That’s not a small feat. Let’s see if they can keep it up in the second half.
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 10:04 PM GMT reply actions
I doubt they will
Pep will find a way to turn it around.
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
Well there's that
Scoring from a corner kick: so easy, even a cave man can do it.
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 10:08 PM GMT reply actions
Remember that no matter who wins this...the real winner is football*
*provided Barca wins, otherwise it’s a travesty and anti-football
by Culain on Jan 18, 2012 10:11 PM GMT up reply actions 1 recs
He's a dick
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
is there anyone here going for barca lmao.. not that i am but it seems to me everyone is looking for them to lose
Where is the meatloaf?
Their only use in my opinion
Was to destroy Santos and show how Brazilian soccer isn’t the marvelous thing most pundits here try to show. I’m neutral about both of them, even though I really like Mourinho and Pep.
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
Going for? Not many.
I wouldn’t mind having a go AT a few Barca players though. I’m pretty fantastic at handbags.
WTF was that Pepe?
Bullshit. La Liga is the worst
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 10:24 PM GMT reply actions
I really dislike farca....i cant stand the diving.... their superiority complex..... and all their "new "fans
Where is the meatloaf?
You can stand Real Madrid??
They dive see Pepe see Cr7 for superiority complex
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:27 PM GMT up reply actions
And Messi just got shot
This game is a joke. Why can’t such good teams just play?
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 10:28 PM GMT reply actions
Pepe stepped on his hand, I don't begrudge him rolling around.
by Cablinasian on Jan 18, 2012 10:30 PM GMT up reply actions
I give Messi the benefit of the doubt.
Criticize a guy for diving, fine, but it hurts for a 200 lb man to step on your hand with studs.
by Cablinasian on Jan 18, 2012 10:33 PM GMT up reply actions
and if it takes rolling around for Pepe to receive the red card he deserves, then fine.
by Cablinasian on Jan 18, 2012 10:33 PM GMT up reply actions
If they redcarded everyone that deserved one this game we'd likely have a 2 on 2 contest
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 10:34 PM GMT up reply actions
it's about the most clear-cut red possible.
and I’d rather they send off everyone who deserves it. Maybe the next Clasico would be a better game.
by Cablinasian on Jan 18, 2012 10:36 PM GMT up reply actions
Rolling around to draw attention is the root of all evil
And is certainly no excuse. Get better/more refs. Institute post-game video replays/fines. Don’t excuse play-acting and cheating.
Messi generally stays on his feet and doesn't exaggerate contact.
He acted hurt because of a legitimately dirty play that should have resulted in a red card. He’s not cheating. Pepe’s hurting the sport with his crap, Busquets is hurting it with his. Messi’s the best superstar we have at playing it straight.
by Cablinasian on Jan 18, 2012 10:38 PM GMT up reply actions
I agree with your first sentence at least. He's an animal and I hate his guts.
Plus, he has a very, very, punchable face.
Inapropriate
But true.
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
Just heard from the ESPN Brazil narrator
Pato scored the goal which will probably send Milan to the next phase of Italian Cup, but went out of the game injured.
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
Pato scored and got injured.
That is certainly characteristic.
by Cablinasian on Jan 18, 2012 10:34 PM GMT up reply actions
So much hope for the "white Ronaldo"...
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
really? i like pato but for people to compare him to el fenomeno is outrageous
Where is the meatloaf?
I'm used to it
They’re saying the same about Leandro Damião.
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
Pepe is the biggest turd in the bunch
And that’s impressively awful
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 10:35 PM GMT reply actions
At least he doesn't pretend to be all noble and shit, unlike Biscuits or Pedro
But hey, I liked Vinnie Jones, too.
Cesc is quickly catching him
I always liked him with Arsenal, but he’s seemed a real piece of shit all season
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 10:38 PM GMT up reply actions
it's a Barca thing.
I used to really like Sanchez.
by Cablinasian on Jan 18, 2012 10:38 PM GMT up reply actions
I would say ronaldo and zidane have been by far the two best players ive seen in my life
Where is the meatloaf?
Then its okay
For a moment I thought you are drunk
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:41 PM GMT up reply actions
Abidal
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
why is it that everybody in barca can finish.....we shoot like 30 shots to score one
Where is the meatloaf?
Roids
1970 - 1984 - 2010
"Vamos Fluzão, vamos ganhar
Eu sou do clube tantas vezes campeão!
Vim pra torcer, vim pra gritar
E por você a vida inteira vou cantar!"
As much as Barcelona is Barcelona
I root for them over Real Madrid every time. My least favorite players in the world are Cristiano Ronaldo, Pepe, and Wayne Rooney. 2 out of 3. Can’t root for them. Just can’t do it.
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 10:41 PM GMT reply actions
Love you brother
Replace Pepe with Neymar and you have my list of most hated player.
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:42 PM GMT up reply actions
and Kevin-Prince Boateng. Fuck that guy.
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 10:42 PM GMT up reply actions
I respect that... i really dislike both of them
I only respect iniesta, puyol, abidal, messi, sanchez, villa for the starting 11
Where is the meatloaf?
No they are out of Cl
So no chance of playing real Madrid that’s what it is
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:49 PM GMT up reply actions
Coentrao and Pepe should be suspended for the 2nd leg
if there is any justice in this world.
by FootieFromAfar on Jan 18, 2012 10:52 PM GMT reply actions
World player of the year right there...
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 10:54 PM GMT up reply actions
Dint take that away from him
He deserves it. The guy who finished is double the actor.
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 10:55 PM GMT up reply actions
I don't know how I keep getting sucked into watching El Crapico
I keep thinking I’ll get to see two fantastic teams play a great game and instead see 22 players simultaneously rolling around on the ground randomly clutching body parts.
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 10:58 PM GMT reply actions 2 recs
That game was great until Barca scored
by Graham MacAree on Jan 18, 2012 10:59 PM GMT up reply actions
You always get about 30 good minutes
Once the first yellow comes out though it turns into crap
by Stephen Schmidt on Jan 18, 2012 11:00 PM GMT up reply actions
It should have
That would at least have been fun.
by Archit Arya on Jan 18, 2012 11:00 PM GMT up reply actions
Yeah
pretty much every mayor derby game in the EPL is better than the Clasico.
by Sabrina Dessipe on Jan 18, 2012 11:03 PM GMT up reply actions
does anybody remember what was the starting 11 that beat barca, when mourihno was at inter?
Where is the meatloaf?
Read the summary of the match minutes ago
and was glad I didn’t watch it :P Comments here seem to give a similar picture of some reviews
Tor ilisar'thera'nal!

by 
















